- 2022, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2021, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2020, no reunion (covid)
- 2019, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2018, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2017, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2016, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2015, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2014, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2013, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek *
- 2012, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek *
- 2011, Nancy & Ken, Penns Creek
- 2010, Patti & Paul, Rockwood †
- 2009, Patti & Paul, Rockwood †
- 2008, Ann Jean & Tom, Finger Lakes †
- 2007, Ann Jean & Tom, Finger Lakes
- 2006, Hocking Hills
- 2005, Hocking Hills
- 2004, Peggy, Warren
- 2003, Peggy, Warren
- 2002, Jane & Chris, Cincinnati (girls only)
- 2001, Toronto
- 2000, Ann Jean & Tom, Rochester
- 1999, Joyce & Ray, Camp
- 1998, Joyce & Ray, Camp
- 1997, Ann Jean & Tom, Rochester
- 1983, Edinboro
- 1982, “Lake Lieb”
* Photos by Peggy
† stereo